Every Version of You by Natalie Messier — A Second Chance at Eighteen and a Choice Between Two Loves
Book Summaries
November 22, 2026
By NPOWS New
Joey Vasquez is thirty-two, a corporate lawyer in Los Angeles with a strained family life and a secret she has carried for fourteen years: she is in love with her best friend, Elijah Aarons. At one of Elijah's dinner parties, Joey also has to put up with Alex Aquino, a man she cannot stand. Then a car accident ends Joey's life, and she finds herself offered something extraordinary: a do-over. She wakes up at eighteen, in her first year of college, the year she first met both Elijah and Alex. Armed with the memories of her first life, she sets out to win Elijah this time, only to find herself drawn, against all expectations, to Alex.
Every Version of You was published on 7 July 2026 by Gallery Books. It is Natalie Messier's debut novel; she was a Reese's Book Club LitUp Fellow, a programme that supports emerging writers.
Second chances and roads not taken
The book asks a tempting question: if you could go back and make different choices, knowing what you know now, would your life be better? Joey's second chance lets her revisit her family, her friendships and her career as well as her love life, and the answers are rarely what she expects.
Romance with a philosophical edge
Alongside the love story, Messier explores life, death and the decisions we make with the time we have. The publisher describes it as a captivating, philosophical and romantic exploration of exactly that, and promises a surprising reveal in the final act.
What reviewers are saying
Its publisher pitches it to fans of The Seven Year Slip and The Love of My Afterlife, and describes it as a magical, moving adventure about second chances, with emotional range and a surprising final act. Readers who dislike second-chance or time-travel premises may find the setup familiar, but the heart of the book is Joey's growth.
Who will enjoy it
This is for readers who loved The Seven Year Slip, The Midnight Library or One Day, and anyone who enjoys romantic fiction with a speculative twist. It deals with death, grief and family conflict, so it is an emotional read, but it is ultimately hopeful.