Start reading instantly or explore by category

The Third Face - Part One This Week's Spotlight · Thriller

The Third Face - Part One

by Virender Jaiswal

The video had been live for forty minutes when Vasanthi Rajagopal watched herself say something she had never said.

She sat in her car outside the newsroom with her phone propped on the steering wheel. It was her face, her green cotton salwar suit, her habit of tucking her hair behind the left ear before a hard sentence. Ninety seconds long.

"Sources inside the Rashtriya Navodaya Party confirm that the party's treasurer routed campaign money through the Sri Vinayaka Charitable Trust," the other Vasanthi said. "And that the death of candidate Prakash Deshpande was not an accident."

She stopped listening after that. The other Vasanthi went on for another minute, calm and unhurried, and then the clip ended. Twenty-one lakh views.

Her phone buzzed. Unknown number: You should have stayed quiet.

Then another. Everyone knows your face.

By midnight the hashtag had a name. By two, someone had posted her home address. By three she was in a lodge on the edge of the city, registered under her cousin's name, listening to the corridor.

The worst part was that the video was right.

She had been on the Sri Vinayaka Trust for eight months and had never published a word, because she couldn't prove the Deshpande part. The trust, the treasurer, the brake failure that had been ruled an accident: it was all in a notebook in her bag, in her handwriting. Someone had taken that and put it in her mouth.

Whoever did this didn't want to embarrass her. They wanted her dead, or close to it. And they knew the story was true.

That took a while to sink in. For the first hour she couldn't think at all. She watched it with the sound off, then on, then frame by frame, looking for the join. The suit was hers. The light behind her was the window of her own study. She actually asked herself whether she had recorded this and forgotten, sitting on the edge of the bed. That scared her more than the messages. She went back through the month: every shoot, every voice note, every time she'd practised a question in the mirror. Nothing. She had never said those words to a camera.

Then how is it my voice?

She had done a segment on deepfakes once, nodding at an expert. It had felt like a story about other people. Now the other Vasanthi blinked on the screen and the blink was right, and she understood that anyone with enough footage could do this to her.

She checked the account that uploaded it. Created that morning, no name, no history, nothing to hold on to.

She put the phone face down and made herself breathe the way she did before a hostile interview. One question at a time. To make this, someone needed her footage. To say what it said, someone needed the notebook. That was a short list, and she didn't want to look at it.

She wrote three lines on a clean page. Her hand wasn't steady on the third.

Dinesh.
Smita.
Or someone else?

Dinesh Kamath was her husband for another three months, until the divorce came through. Fourteen years ago he had been her editor at a small weekly, the man who taught her to read a balance sheet. She'd reported to him once. Now he ran an independent channel with a few thousand subscribers and almost no sponsors, and he still lived in the house, in the other bedroom, because neither of them could afford to leave first.

They shared the study. Her laptop sat on the desk they'd bought together, on the days she didn't want the newsroom.

Somewhere in the last four years the numbers had flipped. Her stories got the readers and the invitations. His got sympathy. At a dinner last year someone asked him what he did and she heard him say, "I used to be her editor."

She hadn't forgotten that.

The laptop was never locked at home, because who locks a laptop in her own house? Years of raw footage sat on it, her face from every angle. Anyone making a deepfake would want exactly that.

Three weeks ago she had come down the stairs and heard him in the study on the phone with a man she'd never met, someone he called "the funding." "She's the brand," Dinesh was saying. "Brands can be replaced." He stopped when he saw her and said it was his mother.

And the Tuesday before the video, she'd noticed a login on her laptop at 2:14 in the morning. Her own account, while she was asleep upstairs. She asked him over breakfast and he said, too fast, "I needed to check my mail. Why are you auditing me?"

She hadn't pointed out that he had his own laptop. It hadn't made sense then. It did now.

Then tonight. She called him from the lodge and he picked up on the first ring and didn't ask where she was. Everyone else had asked.

Memories started coming, one after another, without her asking. The stairwell. The dinner. Dinesh at the study desk at midnight with the screen lit up, and her never wondering what he was looking at.

The last one bothered her most. The night her first big story ran, when he was still her editor, he'd picked her up off the floor of the old office, laughing, saying we did it. That was true too.

She wrote under his name: Just tired of being the furniture? Maybe. But why?

She didn't know the answer.

Smita Bhatt was the second name, and the easiest to hate.

They'd come up together and chased the same sources. Years ago, on a panel, Smita had said into the microphone, "Vasanthi's gift is that she's fearless. Mine is that I'm careful," and the audience laughed. Vasanthi went home and threw a steel tumbler at the wall.

Smita ran the investigations desk at a rival channel now, and she had been trying to get the party story for a year. For some months she had also been the favourite target of every handle that hated the party. They called her Navodaya's paid anchor. Someone kept posting photographs of her standing near the party's people at press events. Vasanthi had seen them go by on her feed and had scrolled on. It was what happened to anyone on television.

Eleven minutes after the video appeared, Smita posted a long thread. Measured, calm, calling for verification before outrage. In the fourth post was the Trust's registration date, which wasn't in the video and wasn't well known.

In March, Smita had pitched this exact story to her own editor and been turned down for lack of proof. A mutual friend had told Vasanthi, and also what Smita said afterwards in front of people: "Vasanthi doesn't need proof. She just needs the right face on camera."

Then the photograph that someone sent round that evening: Smita at a café near the party headquarters, two days before the leak, leaning across a table toward the party's spokesman. Vasanthi looked at it for a long time.

And at dawn, a reporter on the hashtag dug out that the account which first posted the video had followed exactly four people when it was created. Smita was one.

She wrote: Competitor. Motive yes. Means probably. Then, because it was four in the morning, Does she want me dead, or just off the story?

Who else? Ramanathan Iyer? But why would he? She picked up the pen and put it down again. Maybe not. She closed her eyes. She was torn.

He was executive editor of the network. He'd built the Ledger Desk around her nine years ago and given her the money and the room and, early on, something harder to get, which was somebody believing her. He came to the house when her father died and sat with her mother for two hours without saying anything clever. He still asked after her mother every other day.

When the video broke he was the first to call. He already had a lawyer on the line, a security man, and a safe house on offer that she hadn't taken. "Do the right thing," he said. "Whatever happens. I'll handle the rest." She cried on the phone and was embarrassed about it now.

But there was more...

Months back she'd shown him a draft on the Trust. He read it, took his glasses off, and said, "This is brilliant, Vasanthi. But we can't run it yet. Legal won't touch the Deshpande angle. Give it to me. Let me see what we can do with it." She said no. It was her story and she wanted to finish it. He smiled and patted her shoulder. He never asked who her sources were. She noticed that only now.

In June, at the quarterly review, Surendra Agarwal, the network's biggest investor, wanted her piece on the minister's land deal softened. He said so across the boardroom table with eleven people there. She told him, louder than she meant to, that he wasn't funding a newsroom, he was funding a PR office. Agarwal went very quiet and left before the tea came.

Ramanathan called her to his cabin that evening and looked tired. "He asked me if the Ledger Desk is worth the trouble," he said. "Do you know what it costs me to keep you? Every quarter, a new fight." Then he smiled and put his hand over hers. "Don't worry. I'll handle Agarwal."

She left lighter than she came in. Halfway down the corridor she remembered her pen, went back, and heard him through the half-open door on the phone, in a voice she didn't know. "She won't be managed. That's the problem with her." He looked up and saw her and his face changed so fast she almost doubted she'd heard it.

A few weeks later there was talk in the newsroom that Agarwal was selling his shares. Nobody said it to her.

The week before the video, Ramanathan asked to take her notebook overnight so legal could glance at the timeline. It came back the next morning with a sticky note: Excellent work. Protect this. It felt thicker when she took it back. She'd thought she was imagining that.

After the leak he told her not to go to the police yet. "It'll leak. Let me work my channels first."

She wrote, next to all of it: He's the only one who looked after me. Not likely. Then she crossed out her notes on Ramanathan.

Then, below the names, almost as an afterthought, she wrote the party and looked at it. They had the most to lose. But why would they make a video that told the world their secret? Unless someone wanted them to hunt her, and wanted it to look like she'd brought it on herself.

She wrote Agarwal? He had the power, and the rumour was that he was selling his shares. But he didn't know the notebook existed. She crossed out his name.

Dinesh, who was leaving her. Smita, who wanted her story. Ramanathan, who had never raised his voice to her in nine years. Or someone she did not know...

If she accused the wrong one she'd have ruined an innocent person on the worst night of her life. If she accused nobody she'd be dead by Friday.

At dawn she was still at the lodge's one wobbly table with a glass of tea gone cold, reading the transcript of the video for the tenth time, the way she'd read a deposition.

"...routed campaign money through the Sri Vinayaka Trust..."

"...the death of candidate Prakash Deshpande was not an accident."

All of that was public, or guessable. The Trust's name had been in a filing for months. The brake failure was in every archive.

Near the end, under the closing music, the other Vasanthi said one more line. She'd missed it the first forty times.

"...and the final transfer cleared on the ninth, through an account ending four-one-seven."

She stopped breathing.

She turned the pages of her notebook to find it. Final transfer, 9th. Acct ending 417. Her handwriting, small and cramped.

She hadn't put that number in an email, a draft, or any file on any laptop. It was on that page and in her head. And she had said it out loud exactly once, in the last week before the video, in a room with the lamp on.

In the gravel yard outside, a car door slammed. Then another. Then footsteps on the stairs, more than one person.

A few seconds later, there was a knock on the door.

A man's voice, calm and polite. "Open the door, Vasanthi."

Her body stiffened, as if she had sensed that this might be the end.

Read Full Story →

More Stories

Browse All Stories →
The Rite of Ending
The Rite of Ending

Bhuvan sat cross-legged under the old peepal tree in his backyard.

The ancestral house behind him was over a century old, built by a renowned local Tantra practitioner. Now, it was crumbling. Strips of paint curled off the damp brickwork, black moss suffocated the northern wall, and the sour smell of wet lime and mildew hung heavy in the air. Four of the eleven upstairs bedrooms were roofless ruins, their wooden ceiling beams sticking up like the house had fangs.

He checked his watch: 12:30 AM.

One more hour.

The humiliation from three weeks ago was still raw. During the second-year project review, in front of forty classmates, Nagraj had casually picked up Bhuvan’s printout. He didn't yell; he just read the first sentence in a mocking, theatrical drawl and asked the room, "Does anyone actually understand this garbage? My son in fifth standard could have done better research on Shakespeare. Maybe you should consider… "

Even before Mr. Nagraj finished, someone chuckled, and within seconds, the whole room erupted. Nobody backed Bhuvan up. Bhuvan had stood there frozen, clutching a useless laser pointer while the professor marked his register without even looking up. He hadn't cried until he reached the fire exit stairwell.

Now, he rested his phone on a root and shone its flashlight onto the brittle, yellowed pages of an old family manuscript.

Marana. The Rite of Ending.

He read the instructions once. Then he read them again, his nerves settling as the decision took root.

Using a lump of soft charcoal, he cleared the dead leaves and scraped a complex geometric yantra directly into the dirt. In the center, he wrote Nagraj's name, set a printed photo beside it, and lit a small brass lamp. The tiny orange flame barely cut through the oppressive dark.

“Four minutes,” he murmured, looking at his watch one more time.

His palms were dripping sweat. He wiped them on his jeans. His heart was beating so fast it felt as though it might pop out of his chest.

He killed his phone light. The darkness slammed shut around him. His hands wouldn't stop trembling, no matter how many times he pressed them flat against his knees.

Bhuvan began to chant. His shaky voice stumbled over Sanskrit syllables he'd memorized but barely understood.

Then, every ambient sound died. The crickets, the croaking frogs near the well, the neighbor’s stray dog. All of them fell silent at once. The dead silence made Bhuvan's own voice sound horribly loud. But he did not stop, he kept chanting.

An icy breath grazed his cheeks, just as the book had warned, then moved to his neck — a splinter of ice driven into his skin and slowly turned, the cold spreading down his backbone until it had claimed his entire body. He tried to turn his head and couldn't; all he could manage was a glance down at the lamp, its flame tugged hard sideways, bending toward the black space behind his shoulder. Then something seized him and spun him around, sharp and merciless, and slammed him onto the ground.

He looked up.

Nothing. Just ruined walls and hollow window frames.

Then came the stench: wet dirt, rotten leaves, and a sharp, metallic copper tang that coated the back of his throat like blood.

The temperature plummeted. Bhuvan’s breath turned to white mist. A thin layer of low fog crawled across the dirt toward his drawn circle, stopped for a second, and then pushed forward anyway with twice the speed. It moved straight against the direction of the wind.

He realized his chanting had stopped some time ago. He tried to chant but his jaws refused to move.

He could hear his heart slamming against his ribs. Thump. Thump.

And right beneath it, out of sync, came a second heartbeat. Heavy, slow, and deep beneath the dirt.

While he was still gasping for breath, Bhuvan was suddenly lifted from the ground and hurled toward the yantra. He landed directly in front of it. The charcoal lines began to shift on their own, squirming through the soil. Nagraj's name vanished. In its place, thick, muddy letters pushed up from underground, spelling out a new name:

B H U V A N

The lamp went out instantly. A crushing force slammed down on his shoulders and drove his face into the mud. Grit jammed under his fingernails. His throat locked tight; he tried to scream for his father, but only a dry rasp came out. A sickening whine filled his ears, and right beside his cheek, he heard slow, heavy breathing that offered no warmth.

Something invisible clamped around his left ankle and yanked.

Bhuvan skidded across the dirt, his shoulder slamming hard into a tree root. He clawed wildly at the earth, but his body remained completely paralyzed. He could only listen to that heavy second heartbeat syncing with his own frantic pulse.

The neighbouring trees began to sway violently, their roots groaning as though they were about to tear free.

Then, just as suddenly, the crushing weight on his chest eased slightly.

The thing holding his ankle let go, retreating into the shadow of the tree. Bhuvan gasped, dragging air back into his burning lungs.

Heavy barefoot steps pounded across the patio. A door crashed open.

"Bhuvan!"

His father sprinted into the courtyard, hair wild, holding a lit brass lamp. His eyes darted to the extinguished circle, then to the altered symbols in the mud. His face turned ghost-white. He knew the shape at once.

"What did you do?" his father breathed.

Bhuvan couldn't speak; he just sobbed, choking on dirt.

His father stepped directly between Bhuvan and the tree, his body rigid. "Don't look behind me."

His father felt it immediately. The familiar, ice-cold presence was gathering just behind his back. It had come closer than before. Its cold breath touched the nape of his neck. But it did not attack. It simply waited.

His father began to chant. Low. Precise. Each syllable landed with the certainty of something remembered rather than learned.

The old brick walls groaned. Dust rained down from the open beams, and a crack snapped clean through a nearby windowpane. Hot lamp oil sloshed over his father's hand, blistering the skin, but the old man didn't flinch, stagger, or drop the chant.

With one final syllable, the lamp flame flared bright white for a split second. The ground jolted under their feet as if something enormous had just been slammed back underground.

Instantly, the heavy oppressive weight lifted. The neighbourhood noise slowly crept back. Crickets chirped. A distant dog barked.

Bhuvan’s legs buckled, and his father caught him before he hit the ground.

"Did... did I kill it?" Bhuvan choked out.

His father stared silently at the roots of the peepal tree. "No," he said softly. "You opened a door. I only managed to latch it."

Read Full Story →
The Iron Box
The Iron Box

Elias hadn't been to the coast in years, and he'd forgotten the way the salt gets into everything out there -  into your collar, your sleeves, the back of your throat before you're even halfway up the road. By the time he reached the gates he felt a little sick, and he told himself, more than once, that it was just the smell.

The house had gone the way these old places always went once the money ran out. No paint left on it anywhere. The wood had turned gray and soft, and one whole side of the roof had started to sag, like the place had simply gotten tired of holding itself up straight. He'd cleared out houses like this before, three or four of them over the years, so he knew what to expect, more or less. The gate stuck when he pushed on it, then gave all at once, swinging open so fast it caught him off guard.

The lawyer had been clear enough about the job. There was a small iron box up in the study, brass handle, hard to miss. Get that, and he'd get the rest of his money — five thousand pounds, which was more than Elias usually saw in a year, let alone for one night's work. Then, almost like it was an afterthought, right as he was heading out the door, the lawyer had added: don't spend too long looking in any mirrors in the house, and if you hear water running somewhere, just leave. Don't go looking for where it's coming from.

Elias hadn't asked why. Five thousand pounds buys a man a lot of not-asking.

The front door was unlocked, which he didn't think much of at the time. The knocker was shaped like a hand, the fingers just a little too long to be right, and he touched it without really thinking, the way you do, and got a small shock for his trouble, sharp enough to make him swear under his breath.

Inside, the air was warmer than it had any business being, for an empty house in the middle of winter, and underneath the warmth there was a smell;  sweet, and just a bit rotten, like fruit left out too long. He didn't stop to think about where that might be coming from. He lit his lantern anyway, more out of habit than need, since moonlight was already coming down through a skylight thick with grime, enough to make out the staircase and the shapes of furniture buried under old sheets.

Somewhere off to his left, water was dripping. Slow. Steady, like a clock.

He thought about what the lawyer had told him, and then he went and looked anyway, because that's what people do. A row of old portraits ran down the hall, the kind rich families used to have painted, and every single one of them had had its eyes cut out — not torn, cut clean, like whoever did it had taken their time. From one of the empty sockets, in a painting of a woman in a lace collar, something dark had leaked out and was still making its way down the canvas.

That wasn't water. Water doesn't move like that.

"Just get the box," he said out loud, mostly to hear his own voice doing something ordinary, and started up the stairs.

The banister was wet under his hand and he didn't ask himself why. The stairs groaned with every step, loud enough that he half expected the whole staircase to give out under him, and somewhere around the fourth step he started talking to himself, quietly, just to keep moving.

"Okay," he muttered. "Okay, that's fine. Just wood settling. Fifteen more steps, maybe less." He counted them off in his head as he climbed. "Ten more. You do this, you get five thousand pounds. Ten more steps for five thousand pounds. That's nothing."

By the time he stopped noticing the groaning under his boots, the warm air from downstairs had given out completely, and the cold that took its place had a strange, wet edge to it, the kind that seems to reach the back of your teeth.

There was a mirror at the top of the stairs, tall and old, the glass gone dark and cloudy. He hadn't been warned about that one exactly -  just mirrors in general -  but walking past it without looking felt more strange than looking would, so he looked.

His reflection was a half-second slow to catch up with him. Not by much. Just enough that he noticed. He didn't stick around to see if it happened again.

He found the study, and the box was sitting right where the lawyer had said it would be, on a desk buried under years of undisturbed paper. It was lighter than it looked, which felt like good news for about three seconds, right up until he lifted it and something inside shifted — not the way things usually shift when you pick them up, but the way something with real weight shifts when it decides, on its own, to move.

That was when he heard the tapping behind him. Slow. Even. Fingernails on glass.

He turned around before he'd decided to.

Something stood in the doorway, tall in a way that didn't look impressive so much as wrong, the proportions a little off, like someone had tried to draw a person from a description they'd only half heard. It had no face to speak of. Just smooth skin where a face should be, and a single long opening across the middle of it that worked like a mouth.

Elias's breath went ragged. His hands shook hard enough that he nearly dropped the box.

The thing opened its mouth, and what came out sounded like someone trying to breathe with water in their lungs.

Elias didn't wait around to find out what it wanted. He put his shoulder through the study window and went straight out onto the balcony, glass and all, into fog so thick he couldn't see the ground, just hear the sea somewhere far below, working at the rocks the way it probably had for a hundred years before he was ever born.

The thing followed him through the broken window, and the glass didn't slow it down even a little.

His back hit the stone railing, and there was nowhere left to go.

The box under his arm started moving again, small scratching sounds coming from somewhere inside it, and he noticed, in a distant sort of way, that the rhythm matched his own heartbeat, almost exactly.

The creature stopped where it was. It tilted its head to one side, slow, with a sound like knuckles cracking, almost like it was curious.

Then it reached out one long finger and laid it on top of the box.

The cold went through the metal and into his chest all at once, and his heart gave one hard, painful stumble before it just stopped altogether. The sound of the sea faded out to nothing. And the last thing he felt, before there wasn't anything left to feel it with, was a hand closing around his throat, slow and almost gentle, like whoever it belonged to had all the time in the world.

They found him on the balcony three days later, when someone finally came looking. The box was still there, sitting a few feet from the body, untouched. Nobody wanted to be the one to pick it up so it stayed there. 

The coroner called the death a heart attack. 

A few months after that, the lawyer put the word out again. He needed someone new — someone who needed the money badly enough not to ask too many questions about the last man who'd taken the job, or the one before him.


Read Full Story →
GrassGo
GrassGo
Riya walked into the kitchen, poured herself a cup of coffee, and reached for the biscuit tin. She took one bite. "Hmm..." Her mother did not look up from the potatoes. She had been peeling potatoes for thirty years. She could detect a business idea from two rooms away. "I know that 'hmm.'" "What 'hmm'? I didn't say anything." "You said hmm." "That's just a sound." "That sound cost us fourteen thousand rupees when you decided to sell handmade soaps from the bathroom." Riya opened her mouth. "The bathroom still smells of lavender," her mother added. "It has been four years." Riya closed her mouth. Then opened it again, because she was constitutionally unable not to. "Biscuits haven't changed in years." "They're biscuits." "But imagine if—" "No." "You don't even know what I was going to say." "Healthier. Organic. Premium. Sell online. Disrupt the category." Her mother peeled a potato with the calm of someone who had given this speech before. "Did I miss anything?" Riya stared at her. "...Subscription model," she said quietly. Her mother put down the peeler. Not aggressively. Just with the weight of a woman who needed a moment. "Last week," she said, "mushroom farm." "I watched one video. It was very convincing." "The week before, mobile car wash." "People need clean cars, Mummy." "And before that, you wanted to rent goats." A pause. "To eat weeds," her mother clarified, in case Riya had forgotten the details. "You wanted to charge people to borrow goats. To eat their garden weeds. As a service." "Agri-tourism is a growing sector—" "Riya." "The goats basically do the work themselves—" "Riya." "I had a name for it and everything. GrassGo." Her mother picked the peeler back up. This was her coping mechanism. As long as there were potatoes, she could survive anything. Her father walked in at this precise moment, which was either terrible timing or a gift from God, depending on who you asked. He was still in his reading glasses. He had a newspaper under one arm and the expression of a man who had heard everything from the hallway and was choosing, wisely, to pretend otherwise. He looked at his wife. He looked at his daughter. He looked at the biscuit tin on the counter. "What are we opening today?" This was not a joke. He asked this every time. It had started as a joke, years ago, and had since become simply how mornings worked in this house. "A biscuit company," said her mother. He set down his newspaper. Took off his glasses. Polished them on his shirt — which he only did when he was thinking seriously — and put them back on. "Good. We already have customers." Riya looked at him. "We do?" "Our family. Three packets a week. I checked." "You checked?" "I keep a rough household expenditure log." He said this as if it were completely normal. Because for him, it was. "Biscuits are the fourth largest recurring cost after groceries, electricity, and your mother's insistence on buying whole spices when the ground ones work perfectly well." "I heard that," said her mother. "It was meant to be heard." He sat down at the table. "Three packets a week is one hundred and fifty-six packets a year. Multiply that across even a small apartment complex—" "Papa." "I'm just saying the unit economics are interesting." Riya turned to her mother with the expression of someone who had just discovered their accomplice had been hiding in plain sight for thirty years. Her mother pointed to the chair. "Sit. Both of you, sit." They sat. She reached into the tin, held out a biscuit to Riya, and said nothing for a moment. Just looked at her daughter — this ridiculous, wonderful, exhausting person she had made — with the kind of love that doesn't have a cleaner word for it. "Do you want one more?" Riya took it. "For the next ten minutes," her mother said, "you are not the founder of anything. You are not disrupting any category. The goats are retired. GrassGo is not happening." "What am I then?" "A customer. Eating a biscuit. That's all." Riya dipped it into her coffee and ate it. The kitchen was quiet. Her father had, very discreetly, taken out a small notebook. He was not writing in it. He was simply holding it. Just in case. Her mother looked at him. He put the notebook away. She looked back at Riya. "I think we're safe," she whispered. Riya stared at the tin. Then at the shelf behind it, where three other brands sat in a row. Same beige. Same font. Same picture of wheat doing nothing interesting. She swallowed the last of the biscuit. "...Although. Look, Papa already sees it. Three packets a week, you said it yourself. That's not a habit, that's a dependency. We're not selling biscuits, we're selling the thing people reach for without thinking—" Her father nodded slowly. "The repeat purchase rate alone—" "Exactly! And if we go healthier, we open a whole new—" "The margins on premium could be significant—" "Papa gets it. Papa completely gets it." They were both leaning forward now. The notebook was back on the table. Riya was gesturing at the tin. Her father was nodding in the way he nodded when something made numerical sense to him. Her mother set down the peeler. She looked at her daughter. She looked at her husband. She looked at the biscuit tin sitting between them like it had called this meeting. "Shut up," she said. They shut up. She picked up the peeler again. But she was smiling. Just a little. Just enough.
Read Full Story →
Grief Has Choreography
Grief Has Choreography

There's no dignified way to say this, so here it is plainly: Today I found myself washing a dog's pee mat while doing a full Sufi-style spin to a heartbreak song, singing at a volume my neighbours did not consent to. Nobody warns you that grief has choreography. You probably have figured by now, I was mourning a heartbreak but what if I add to it that the heartbreak was more than 20 years ago and the recent adjacent event was a bad review at work. I think you would probably now agree with me, I might be crazy except I am really not. Trust me!If someone had walked in on any of that, they'd have assumed I lost it too, and maybe I did just not in the way they assume.

What I was doing, instinctively, is what humans have always done with a feeling too big to sit still with; even when it looks, from the outside, like a fully choreographed breakdown.And then, mid-spin, I started thinking: I'm a pretty logical person. But then suddenly something happens, the logic goes out of the window, and the fragile emotional self of 20 years comes back.That's the sentence that started this whole piece. And if you've lived even one version of it, you already know there's a particular kind of night that goes with it.

Maybe yours looks different. You open your phone and start adding things to a cart you'll never check out. Or you stand in front of the fridge at midnight, eating spoonfuls of something straight from the tub, not because you're hungry, but because you need something to do. Or you put on a song and just sit there, replaying it for the fourth time, even though it's making things worse, not better.Here's the part that's harder to explain: the thing that set it off probably wasn't even that big. A disappointment. A door that quietly closed. And yet somehow, mid-spin, or by the third spoonful, or the tenth item in the cart, you're not just sad about the small thing anymore. You're back in something from years ago, something you thought you'd already made peace with. The logical, composed person you usually are has stepped out of the room, and a much younger, much more fragile version of you has taken their place.

My analytic brain quickly jumped to pattern, "Hey, on normal days, I can pretty much live without this feeling," is how it got described, looking back. "It really doesn't bother me otherwise. But when something else falls apart, I feel like I'm drowning within the same pain I experienced 20 years back."That sentence is more useful than it sounds. Because it's not really about one heartbreak. It's about something almost everyone has felt and very few people have language for: the way old pain seems to come back to life the moment new pain shows up.

Your Brain Doesn't File Memories By Date. It Files Them By Feeling. Your memory isn't organized like a calendar. It's organized like a mood board.In the early 1980s, a researcher named Gordon Bower ran a series of experiments where he put people into a sad or happy mood and then asked them to recall memories from their lives. He found people in a sad mood pulled up far more sad memories than happy ones, and people in a happy mood did the reverse.

Psychologists call this mood-congruent memory; with your current emotional state acting like a search filter, pulling up other memories that carry the same emotional tone.A closely related idea is state-dependent memory, where something learned or experienced in one emotional or physical state becomes easier to retrieve when you're back in a similar state. Together, the two help explain something that otherwise feels almost mystical: why a feeling, not a fact, can be the thing that drags an old memory back into the room.Think of memory less like a filing cabinet labelled by year, and more like a web where every memory is tied by threads to a feeling. A disappointment from this year isn't stored next to other things that happened this year. It's stored next to every other disappointment you've ever felt, regardless of whether one was about a job and another was about a person who left.

So when something painful happens today, your brain doesn't just retrieve that one event. It tugs the thread labelled "not chosen," or "alone," or "let down," and everything tied to that thread comes with it. The new pain isn't causing the old pain to resurface. It's unlocking it - because underneath, they're wired to the same feeling.That's the drowning. Not one wave. All of them, arriving at once, because they were never really separate to begin with.The Part of You That Comes Back Isn't RandomThere's another layer worth naming. The version of you that shows up in these moments often feels younger; less composed, more breakable than the adult who usually runs the show.

That opening line; the logic going out the window, the fragile twenty-year-old self stepping back in, well it isn't a contradiction. Many therapists and psychologists describe experiences like this as emotional regression, though the term is used more often in clinical and therapeutic settings than as a precise, formally tested research construct. The idea is that under enough stress, people's reactions can resemble earlier emotional responses. You don't actually become a child, or the twenty-year-old version of yourself. But your nervous system, under threat, often reaches for the most automatic response it has on file rather than the most recent one. If the rawest version of a particular pain: being left, being unseen, not being enough, that first got wired in years ago, that's the wiring your brain falls back on when something today rhymes with it closely enough.

In my experience,this is why people describe these moments using the language of time travel instead of the language of sadness. Not "I feel sad" but "I feel like I'm back there." That sentence is more literally accurate than most people realize.Why Smart, Pattern-Seeking Minds Get Stuck the LongestPeople who naturally look for patterns and explanations often find unresolved losses especially difficult.You may think, "There must be a pattern here too." But unresolved pain often refuses to give you one.If you're someone who naturally looks for patterns, who isn't satisfied with "things just happen," unresolved pain is especially hard to put down. Psychologist Arie Kruglanski spent decades researching what he called the need for cognitive closure , basically our drive to land on a definite, settled answer, and our discomfort with leaving things open.

Research using Kruglanski's closure scale has shown this need varies from person to person, but people vary in how strongly they seek cognitive closure. The stronger it runs in you, the more your mind treats an unanswered question as something to be solved rather than something to be lived with.This becomes a trap with any loss that never got a clean ending. Your mind keeps searching for the missing piece that would finally make the story make sense: what they were really thinking, what you should have said, why it happened the way it did; because that's what minds wired for closure do with open loops. The problem is that some losses simply don't come with an answer. The story stopped mid-sentence, and your mind keeps trying to write an ending nobody gave it.This searching has a name too: counterfactual thinking, the mental replay of "what if" and "if only." Research on counterfactual thinking shows it's one of the most natural things minds do after a loss, especially one that felt avoidable. Sometimes this kind of replay genuinely helps; it's how we learn from mistakes that can still be corrected. But after a loss that can't be undone, the same replay often stops being useful and just becomes repetitive.

It isn't a flaw in your thinking. It's what thinking does when it's denied an ending.And when the search runs long enough without an answer, it can tip into rumination; going over the same thoughts again, not to find anything new, but because the loop hasn't stopped running. Psychological research consistently associates persistent rumination with depression, anxiety, and prolonged emotional distress, because, unlike genuine reflection, rumination rarely produces a new insight. It just wears the same groove deeper.

Closure Isn't Always Available. That Doesn't Mean You Failed: The goal  most of the time is never to solve the pain. It was to learn to carry it without it taking over the whole room.Which brings us back to the Sufi spin over a half-washed pee mat, the cart full of things you'll never buy, the song on repeat, the tub of ice cream that's now mostly empty."You can't solve everything," is how it gets summed up, "but you can let it out" by affect labelling.

A process that has been shown, including in brain-imaging research, to measurably reduce its intensity, even when nothing about the situation itself has changed. Saying or writing "I'm grieving" or "I feel abandoned" isn't just venting; it appears to reduce activity in brain regions associated with emotional distress. Singing, dancing, scrolling, or eating a tub of ice cream aren't affect labelling in that strict sense, but they often serve a related purpose: letting a feeling move through you instead of staying bottled up. Not every coping habit does this equally well, though, and the difference usually isn't the activity itself. A song on repeat that lets you finally cry is expression. The same song on repeat used to avoid ever sitting still with the feeling is something closer to avoidance. The honest question isn't "is this a healthy coping mechanism," it's whether, afterward, you feel a little more connected to what you're actually feeling, or a little further from it.

Sometimes healing isn't finally understanding what happened. But once you recognise what your mind is doing, it no longer gets to convince you that you've gone backwards. Understanding doesn't erase the pain. It changes what the pain means, and that changes how you choose to process it.A note on the science: Mood-congruent memory and the need for cognitive closure are two of the most extensively researched concepts in psychology, each backed by decades of studies.

Counterfactual thinking, rumination, and affect labelling are similarly well-documented, though affect labelling specifically refers to putting feelings into words, not to coping behaviours more broadly. State-dependent memory and emotional regression are Research using Kruglanski's closure scale has shown this need varies from person to person more loosely across therapeutic and research writing - useful for describing what people experience, even where the evidence is less formally settled. None of this is a diagnosis. It's simply language for something most people feel and few have words for.

Read Full Story →

Books to Explore

Browse All Books →
The Working Version - For the Career You Actually Have
The Working Version - For the Career You Actually Have
A 32-week system built from eighteen years of real workplace experience, stacking one skill on the next, with built-in check-ins for when a habit slips.
by olivia.mukherjee1986
Start Reading →
Nothing Is Wrong with You
Nothing Is Wrong with You
A practical exploration of why we think, feel, and behave the way we do. Blending psychology, neuroscience, and everyday experience, this book helps readers understand the hidden forces shaping stress, motivation, procrastination, habits, and self-worth—so they can work with themselves instead of constantly fighting against themselves.
by olivia.mukherjee1986
Start Reading →
The Invisible Warrior
The Invisible Warrior
In 1939 colonial Madras, a British censor hunts for coded resistance messages in intercepted mail, while a nameless teenage courier smuggles funds hidden in a shipment of timber.
by olivia.mukherjee1986
Start Reading →
7 Years Later...
7 Years Later...
Seven years ago, Mritika lost her mother—and the boy she loved was blamed for her death.

Since then, she has built a life of solitude, burying herself in books and silence. But when an unexpected encounter brings Neel back into her world, the past she fought so hard to escape begins to unravel.

As old memories resurface and mysterious messages appear at her door, Mritika is forced to confront a haunting question: Was Neel truly the killer she believes him to be, or has she spent seven years running from a lie?

A story of love, loss, betrayal, and the truths that refuse to stay buried.
by olivia.mukherjee1986
Start Reading →