The First Time I Saw Him by Laura Dave — Hannah and Bailey Are Back, and So Is Owen
Book Summaries
November 17, 2026
By NPOWS New
Five years have passed since Owen Michaels disappeared, leaving his wife, Hannah Hall, to protect his daughter, Bailey, who was sixteen when he vanished. The two have built a careful, quiet life in Southern California. Then, at a design fair in Los Angeles, Owen suddenly reappears. He has only a moment, but it is long enough to slip Hannah a flash drive full of family photographs that hide a coded message. The criminal organisation Owen has been running from has found them, and Hannah and Bailey must go on the run, following his clues and trusting each other completely, in the hope that they might finally be a family again.
The First Time I Saw Him was published on 6 January 2026 by Scribner and is a Reese Witherspoon Book Club pick. It is the sequel to The Last Thing He Told Me, Laura Dave's 2021 bestseller, which became a streaming series. This summary is spoiler-light for the new book, but its premise does give away parts of the first, so if you have not read The Last Thing He Told Me yet, start there.
A mother and daughter on the run
The heart of the book is the bond between Hannah and Bailey, who are no longer strangers thrown together but stepmother and stepdaughter who have become mother and daughter in every way that matters. Five years on, they have learned how to stay hidden and how to stay alert, and the chase lets both of them show how much they have grown. The story moves from Los Angeles along the California coast and on to Paris, with flashbacks that fill in what Owen has been doing and who he has been dealing with since he vanished.
Love, trust and the cost of protection
Like the first book, this is about what people will do to keep the ones they love safe, and whether that protection is a gift or a burden. Dave keeps asking how well we can ever know someone, and what it means to choose a family rather than be born into one.
What reviewers are saying
Kirkus called it an essential sequel that ties up the loose threads and offers a thrilling ride across continents. Writing for Bookreporter, Rebecca Munro described it as a "madcap dash through international crime" and said Dave "simply never disappoints". The book is faster and more of an international chase than the first, which was a quieter mystery, so readers expecting the same slow unravelling may find the tone different. Fans who wanted to know what happened next have mostly been delighted.
Who will enjoy it
This is for everyone who finished The Last Thing He Told Me wanting more of Hannah and Bailey, and for readers who like domestic suspense that turns into a road-trip thriller. It is short-chaptered and easy to read in a weekend. There is danger and some violence, but nothing graphic, so it suits most adult and older teen readers.