The Unknown by Riley Sager — A Haunted Island, a Cursed Film and Five Women Who Vanished
Book Summaries
November 17, 2026
By NPOWS New
Marin Keane is an actor whose career has stalled, so when she is cast as the lead in a historical horror film, she cannot afford to say no. The film is based on a real mystery. In 1926, five women, all spiritual mediums living together on New Avalon, a fictional island on a fictional Vermont lake called Lake Faraday, disappeared without a trace. One of them, Daisy Rue, left behind a diary, and the film is based on it; Marin is cast as Daisy herself. Before filming, a clause in the cast's contracts requires them to live on New Avalon for a week: period costume, no phones and no modern comforts. Then, once the cameras start rolling, someone else disappears.
The Unknown was published on 4 August 2026 by Dutton in the US and by Hodder in the UK. It is a standalone novel from Riley Sager, the author of Final Girls, Lock Every Door, Home Before Dark and The Only One Left, who has built a big readership on twisty, atmospheric suspense with a touch of the supernatural.
Two timelines, one island
The story moves between Marin's week on the island and extracts from Daisy Rue's diary, so the 1920s and the present slowly reveal each other. The diary chapters fill in the history of the mediums' commune and give the modern mystery its weight, while Marin's chapters supply the creeping dread: an isolated island, a crew with secrets and the growing feeling that the past has not finished with New Avalon.
Grief, belief and who gets heard
Beneath the ghost story are real themes. The book looks at grief and why people reach for the spirit world, at the fashion for spiritualism a century ago, and at how often women, then and now, are dismissed when they say something is wrong. Marin is a flawed narrator, ambitious and sometimes prickly, and that makes her an unpredictable guide.
What reviewers are saying
Reception has been mixed to positive. Kate at The Library Ladies gave it 8 out of 10 and called it a fun, fast-paced return to form, praising the Gothic atmosphere, the genuinely creepy moments and the way the diary entries deepen the island's history. She also found Marin grating at times and some twists predictable. Kirkus enjoyed the eerie mood and an effective early séance, but felt the plot had too many holes, that the final quarter was muddled, and that the long diary passages took some of the tension out of the story. Fiona Alison, reviewing for the Historical Novel Society, enjoyed the gothic tension but found the interwoven timelines confusing at times, with ten names for five characters to keep straight. Readers who come for the setting tend to be happiest.
Who will enjoy it
This is a good pick for readers who like isolated settings, dual timelines and suspense that flirts with the supernatural, and for anyone who enjoyed Sager's Lock Every Door or The Only One Left. If you prefer a tightly logical puzzle, the second half may test your patience, but as a spooky, quick read for a dark evening, The Unknown delivers plenty of chills. It includes peril, death, grief and some frightening scenes, but nothing especially graphic.